While scanning the Feb. 2012 issue of Parenting Magazine, an article on banning the use of crib bumpers caught my attention.
For the last 20 years Mother & baby Matters’ (MbM) practice standards for newborn care have been based on the recommendations of the AAP. Staff are regularly updated on new standards as well as any revisions or changes made to current standards. In October 2011, MbM updated our practice standard on “Back to Sleep/Tummy to Play” when HealthyChildren.org of the AAP released their updated recommendations on reducing the risk of SIDS. These recommendations included bumper pads in the list of objects to be kept out of the crib because they could increase the risk of entrapment, suffocation, or strangulation. The AAP’s position is that research has NOT shown us when it’s 100% safe to have these objects in the crib; however, most experts agree that after 12 months of age these objects pose little risk to healthy babies. The AAP also states that there is no evidence that the bumpers protect against injury.
In the Parenting Magazine article, the author, Marilyn Monroe Rosen draws attention to the latest guidelines released by the AAP on October 21, 2012, urging parents to keep cribs bumper-free as a result of the following:
Reports in the Chicago Tribune during the time frame of late 2010 and early 2011, alleging that federal regulators knew for years that crib bumpers posed a suffocation hazard but failed to warn parents. This coverage pushed the Consumer Product Safety Commission(CPSC) to take a closer look at the safety of crib bumpers, and local governments also have started to act. On Sept. 8, 2011,Chicago became the first U.S city to ban the sale of crib bumpers, and on Sept. 28, 2011, Maryland became the first state to propose a ban an the sale of crib bumpers.
Why Many Parents Are Still Using Bumpers
Why are bumpers still so popular despite building evidence that they aren’t safe? For starters, many parents believe bumpers prevent injury from a baby’s head hitting the sides of a crib, or from limbs getting stuck in the slats. And indeed, bumpers were first conceived to cover the space between crib slats so babies couldn’t fall out or get their heads, arms or legs stuck between the bars. But regulations changed in the 1970s and now mandate less space (just 2 3/8 inches—about the width of a soda can) between slats, making bumpers more of an aesthetic choice than a safety necessity.
As to the question of safety, Rachael Moon, MD, FAAP, of the Children’s National Medical Center in Washington, DC, chairperson of the AAP SIDS task force and lead author of the new guidelines, explains that young babies (for whom bumpers are designed, given that many carry a warning suggesting that they be removed from the crib once a baby can pull himself to standing) don’t have the muscle strength or coordination to fling themselves across the crib hard enough to really injure themselves. Additionally, she adds, while it is possible for a baby to get an arm or a leg stuck between crib slats, it’s virtually impossible to break a limb by doing so—which means that at most, the experience will be uncomfortable and upsetting, but not life-threatening, until a caregiver arrives to help.
Parents also buy bumpers because they think they’re supposed to, given that they’re sold in crib bedding sets, and because they just plain look good, explains Dr. Moon. And there’s little question that modern nurseries tend to look cozier or more “finished” with bumpers, but Dr. Moon added that if parents stop buying bumpers and manufacturers stop making them, perhaps attention will ultimately be focused on other ways of making a nursery look cute.
Bumper Alternatives: Are They Safe?
As an alternative to traditional crib bumpers, some parents have turned to breathable, mesh bumpers or other bumper alternatives, but Dr. Moon said that the AAP does not suggest that parents buy them. “We’re, right now, recommending nothing in the crib, because again, we don’t see the point of it. So, why have something in the crib if it’s not there for a reason?”
Will Retailers Follow Suit?
The AAP now recommends that infants sleep on their backs, alone in a crib on a firm mattress, without any soft objects or loose bedding, which could also be hazardous, ideally in a room shared with a parent. Really, all that’s necessary when it comes to baby bedding is a fitted sheet.
Despite the fact that the AAP warned that crib bumpers could pose a serious safety risk to infants as early as 2008, little has changed when it comes to what expectant parents can find in their local baby super store—in part because baby bedding is big business. The Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association (JPMA) says that at least $50 million worth of infant bedding sets that include bumpers are sold each year, as well as more than 200,000 bumper pad sets.
Unfortunately for parents, it can be confusing to see bumpers on display in stores, not to mention challenging to find crib bedding sold without bumpers, since bedding is often sold in four-piece sets, including a sheet, crib skirt, bumper, and quilt (which doesn’t belong in a safe sleep environment for an infant anyway). But it’s not impossible; Carousel Designs, for example, offers a la carte options for purchasing coordinating fitted crib sheets and crib skirts, and retailers like Babies”R”Us and Buy Buy Baby, as well as web sites like Amazon.com, offer standalone fitted crib sheets.
Dr. Moon said that she hopes retailers will stop selling crib bumpers in response to the AAP’s updated guidelines. “The problem is that a lot of parents don’t understand that the Consumer Products Safety Commission is not a proactive agency; it’s a reactive agency. So, it only recalls things if there’s a problem. It doesn’t approve products before they go on the market. And a lot of parents have this perception that it stores sell it, it must be safe—because if it wasn’t safe, why would people sell it? And that’s clearly not true. I think that it’s important that parents realize that these things are not safe for their babies.”
In the meantime, we can only heighten the awareness of new parents. MbM plans to include this information in our “planning for baby” packet for new clients provided by our doulas at the initial visit.
Read more of the article at http://www.parenting.com/article/sids-prevention?page=0,0
Spread the word and until next time,
Gerri
Gerri Levrini, RN, MSN, CNAA
President & Founder
Mother & baby Matters, Inc.







